Is It Better to Invest in Gold or Diamonds? 3 Key Factorss

investing in gold vs diamonds cover

There are now more ways to invest your money than ever before, so it may seem surprising that some people still prefer to invest the old-fashioned way – in precious metals and diamonds. These two types of investments are more popular than ever before, but they aren’t for all investors.

When examining the pros and cons of investing in gold versus diamonds, it is important to understand the potential of each asset. Gold, historically regarded as a reliable store of value, offers liquidity and a vast marketplace where investors can trade with relative ease. Gold is frequently turned to as a hedge against inflation and currency devaluation, with its price reflecting global economic stability.

Its value is relatively easy to determine due to standardization in weight and purity, making it a popular choice for investors seeking a tangible asset with a recognized value around the world. Whether you are interested in possessing actual gold coins or bars, or you want to trade in gold equities, there are lots of options for you.

Diamonds, on the other hand, present a different set of characteristics appealing to certain investors. They carry intrinsic value, but unlike gold, their worth is not as transparent due to variations in cut, color, clarity, and carat—the four Cs that determine a diamond’s quality and price. These four aspects of a diamond’s value are very subjective and can also change over time.

Although there are obvious benefits to having a nice diamond on your finger, the diamond market is less liquid than gold, and buying or selling diamonds can be a more intricate process. Buying or selling diamonds requires expert appraisal to ensure value. As luxury items, diamonds can also be subject to fluctuations in consumer demand, which can impact their investment potential.

Interestingly enough, when the market is going strong, gold will generally drop in price. Diamonds react to the market in the opposite way. When the market is going strong, people are more prone to purchase diamonds, driving up the price even further.

In light of these attributes, the decision to invest in gold or diamonds is influenced by factors such as market liquidity, ease of valuation, and economic conditions. Other objectives such as risk tolerance, and investment horizon are critical when choosing between these assets.

Gold may be preferred by those seeking stability and wide acceptance as a form of financial insurance, while diamonds may attract those looking for a combination of aesthetic appeal and long-term value appreciation. In other words, your gold coins and bars will be locked away, while you can flaunt your diamond investment on your very own finger!

Understanding Gold as an Investment

Understanding Gold as an Investment

For centuries, investing in gold has been a wise move. It is regarded by many as a strategic financial purchase, involving various methods and affected by numerous global factors. This section dives into the historical significance of gold in economic conditions, the different ways to invest in gold, and the various factors that influence its market value and price volatility. What you will learn is that gold is unique in the way that it is traded, the way that it is held, and the way in which it changes in value over time.

Historical Significance and Economic Conditions

Gold has been considered a store of value for millennia, often seen as a safe haven in times of economic uncertainty. It retains value over time, unlike paper currency, which can be subject to inflation. In periods of inflation, gold typically maintains its purchasing power, making it an attractive hedge for investors. Dollars put away in a savings account will have significantly less value in ten or twenty years due to inflation, while gold put away during that time may be worth more.

Gold Investment Methods

Investors can purchase gold in several forms:

  • Bullion: Physical gold, such as bars or coins that can be held in your possession or by others.
  • Coins: Often collectible items beyond their precious metal content. These are called “numismatic coins” and do not necessarily move in conjunction with the changes in gold prices.
  • ETFs (Exchange-Traded Funds): Securities that track the gold price and can be traded like stocks, providing easier diversification. If you are looking to get in and out of gold purchases often or you just don’t feel the need to physically possess gold coins or bullion, then this would be your best option.

Each method comes with varying levels of liquidity, costs, and physical exposure to the actual metal.

Factors Influencing Gold Price

The price of gold is influenced by:

  • Market Value: Driven by supply and demand, both influenced by global market conditions.
  • Liquidity: Gold’s ability to be easily bought or sold affects its price stability. When the market is down and people are buying up gold, the lack of supply and increased demand will push prices up.
  • Price Volatility: Although less volatile than other assets, its price can fluctuate due to political and economic events. Wars, political unrest, terrorist attacks, and large-scale weather events can all produce moves in price.

Understanding these factors can help you to make informed decisions about incorporating gold into your overall investment strategies.

Exploring Diamond Investment

investing in gold or diamonds

Investing in diamonds involves understanding the nuances of the diamond market and the valuation factors that influence both natural and manufactured diamonds. This is a complicated market, requiring far more expert knowledge than trading in gold, but is an investment that can benefit you over time.

Diamond Market Overview

The diamond market is composed of various segments, each with its distinct characteristics and dynamics. De Beers is one of the most recognized entities in the market, known for its extensive history and influence over global diamond supply. De Beers currently controls approximately 63% of the global diamond market. This involves mining, manufacturing, trading, and retail aspects of their business.

They always say that “Diamonds are a girl’s best friend” – and that is as true today as it was when Marilyn Monroe sang it in 1953. Generally speaking, it is the rarity of diamonds that makes them so valuable. They are difficult, dangerous, and expensive to mine, and the value of diamonds is based on a subjective valuation system.

A significant aspect that investors consider is the rarity of diamonds, which can affect their value substantially. The market is also influenced by the demand for both natural diamonds and manufactured or synthetic diamonds, with the latter becoming increasingly prevalent due to advancements in technology. More and more people are opting for manufactured diamonds, not only because they are more affordable, but because they can be created in unique shapes, sizes, and colors.

Investing in Natural vs Artificial Diamonds

When comparing natural diamonds to artificial diamonds, one must consider specific factors. Natural diamonds are often seen as more desirable for their uniqueness and the ancient processes that formed them, contributing to their rarity. For intrinsic value, real diamonds are the best bet.

However, artificial diamonds offer a less expensive alternative and are identical in appearance to the untrained eye. They also provide consistent quality and can be produced in large quantities. Artificial diamonds may not hold value over time, and for the most part, they look the same in any piece of jewelry.

Natural Diamonds:

  • Rarity: More rare, especially for high-quality stones
  • Valuation: Affected by the 4Cs: Color, Clarity, Cut, Carat

Artificial Diamonds:

  • Manufactured: Less expensive, eco-friendlier options
  • Quality: More consistent due to a controlled production environment

Factors Affecting Diamond Valuation

The value of a diamond is determined by several key factors, often referred to as the 4Cs: Color, Clarity, Cut, and Carat.

  • Color: A colorless diamond is traditionally the most sought-after, and deviations can lead to a decrease in value. When determining a diamond’s value, the color is vitally important.
  • Clarity: Refers to the absence of inclusions and blemishes; higher clarity translates to higher value. After, color, clarity is considered to be the most important aspect in a diamond’s worth.
  • Cut: The quality of the cut impacts the diamond’s symmetry, brightness, and overall aesthetic appeal. Different cuts appeal to different buyers, with some more traditional cuts having a greater value.
  • Carat: Larger diamonds are rarer and thus, typically more valuable. For instance, the Hope Diamond, which is displayed in the Smithsonian Museum is worth upwards of $350 million.

Investors need to evaluate these elements closely since even minor differences can significantly influence a diamond’s market price. Only a true expert can evaluate the true value of any diamond using specific tools.

Comparative Analysis: Gold vs Diamond Investing

Investing in gold or diamonds involves different market dynamics, where gold typically offers greater liquidity. Purchasing diamonds tends to be for more niche investors seeking long-term stability with a higher entry threshold.

Volatility and Market Fluctuations

Gold is known for its relative market stability and is often used as a hedge against inflation and currency devaluation. When the stock market and worldwide economic indicators are positive, the gold market can drop. Market fluctuations for gold are typically less volatile than for diamonds, which are subject to abrupt price changes due to their dependence on fashion trends and the economic health of the luxury sector. The price of gold is generally very stable across the world, making it a standardized commodity, unlike diamonds, whose prices are specific to individual stones’ characteristics. For instance, certain shapes and colors of diamonds may go in and out of style, resulting in price changes over time.

Liquidity and Ease of Trading

The liquidity of gold is considerably higher than that of diamonds. Gold can be quickly bought or sold in numerous forms, such as bullion, coins, or jewelry, at transparent prices. If you own physical gold, then there are probably a few places in your town where you could sell it today. Gold owned in equity form is easily traded on the market.

On the other hand, trading diamonds is more complex due to the need for expert valuation, the variety in quality, and fewer standardized trading platforms. This often translates to a longer process to liquidate diamond investments compared to gold transactions. The supply of high-quality diamonds is limited but the market may vary due to trends and economic indicators.

Investment Horizon and Returns

Gold is often perceived as a safe investment for the long term with returns that are steady over lengthy periods. In contrast, diamonds can yield higher returns, but typically for those with a deeper understanding of the diamond market and a longer investment horizon. It is virtually impossible to buy a diamond in any form today and sell it next year for a considerable profit. However, many people can successfully trade gold in the short term for a profit. The appreciation of a diamond’s value also hinges on its rarity and the market demand for its specific attributes, which requires the investor to have a certain level of expertise in the gemstone market.

Strategic Investment Insights

Strategic investment in gold or diamond hinges on understanding how they can contribute to a balanced investment portfolio, their associated risks, and their behavior under economic uncertainty. These investments should never serve as the majority of your portfolio, but rather as part of an otherwise balanced portfolio of cash, stocks, bonds, mutual funds, and more.

Portfolio Diversification and Asset Allocation

Investors usually diversify their investment portfolio to reduce risk and increase the potential for returns. Gold has traditionally acted as a hedge against inflation and is often negatively correlated with the stock market, adding a layer of safety during market downturns. When the market begins to head north, gold prices will generally begin to drop.

Diamond’s value, on the other hand, is less correlated with market fluctuations and is primarily driven by supply and demand dynamics, which can provide a stabilizing effect on an investment portfolio. In many cases, a strong market will actually lead to higher prices of diamonds as a result of increased demand.

  • Gold: Traditionally used to reduce portfolio volatility.
  • Diamonds: Provides a potentially stable but less liquid investment.

Understanding and Mitigating Risks

While both gold and diamonds have a unique appeal, they also carry distinct risks that investors must consider. They are both risky in their own way, though most experts would say that the potential for profitability with gold is better.


  • Market Risks: Gold prices are sensitive to global economic indicators.
  • Supply Risks: Mining production and geopolitical stability can affect pricing, as can changes in governments, politics, and armed conflicts.


  • Valuation Risks: Diamond valuation is complex and less transparent than gold.
  • Liquidity Risks: Diamonds are harder to sell quickly at fair market prices, regardless of price or size.

Impact of Economic Uncertainty

When COVID-19 started to affect our world, the stock market reacted violently. Had you owned a significant amount of gold during that time, you would have been in a pretty good place. Economic uncertainty often leads investors to reevaluate their asset allocation. Gold’s price usually rises amidst geopolitical tension or financial market disarray due to its perceived store of value.

During that same time, if you had a large amount of your portfolio in diamonds, your assets would have fallen. Diamonds do not experience the same increase in demand during such times, as their market is more driven by consumer demand, particularly for jewelry, which can decline during economic downturns.

  • Gold: Often sees increased demand during economic uncertainty.
  • Diamonds: Demand is more linked to consumer markets and may not increase with economic turmoil.

Practical Considerations

When investing in gold or diamonds, practical considerations such as storage requirements, ease of transactions, and legal factors play critical roles in determining the feasibility and profit potential of these assets. It is important to factor in the cost and hassle of owning both physical gold and diamonds when evaluating them for a potential spot in your personal portfolio.

Storage, Security, and Insurance


  • Storage: Gold requires secure storage solutions such as safes or safety deposit boxes. Small amounts of gold can be held at home, but you will always feel more secure having it held in a secure facility.
  • Security: Physical gold is susceptible to theft and may require additional security measures.
  • Insurance: Typically, insurers offer gold-specific policies to cover potential losses.


  • Storage: Diamonds take up less space but require controlled environments to maintain condition. If your diamond assets are in the form of jewelry, you must also consider that loss may occur if they are worn.
  • Security: Security measures must be discreet yet robust due to diamonds’ small size and high value.
  • Insurance: Specialized insurance is available and recommended due to the individual characteristics of each diamond.

Buying and Selling Strategies


  • Buying: Gold can be bought in various forms, like coins, bars, or ETFs, each with different liquidity and exchange implications. They can be bought online or in person as well.
  • Selling: Selling gold is straightforward, with prices set by global markets, aiding in quick wealth liquidation when necessary. If necessary you can sell physical gold quickly, but usually at a price.


  • Buying: Diamonds are bought for both their industrial value and aesthetic appeal, with purchases often requiring expert verification.
  • Selling: The resale of diamonds can be more complex due to the need for certification and subjective value assessments. These can all serve to influence the price of diamonds.

Legislation and Tax Implications


  • Legislation: Trading gold is subject to federal and state legislation, requiring compliance with trade regulations. Importing physical gold requires adherence to additional laws and regulations.
  • Tax Implications: Gold sales may incur capital gains tax, and specific rules apply to gold investments in IRAs.


  • Legislation: The diamond trade is tightly controlled, with legal standards like the Kimberley Process to prevent “blood diamonds.” These types of diamonds are gems that are mined in war-torn areas and the profits are used to finance further conflict.
  • Tax Implications: Diamonds are taxed via personal property tax and possibly capital gains tax, depending on the nature of the transaction.

These considerations are integral to the decision-making process for investing in either gold or diamonds. Whether you are eager to add gold in any of its forms to your portfolio, or the purchase of a large, unique diamond is more your style, keeping in mind the issues relating to security, authenticity, and potential taxation is vital.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top